Connaught Law News

Immigration Law · Judgment

High Court hears Home Office fundamental dishonesty issue in £7 million detention claim

The High Court (Mansfield J) gave judgment on 6 November 2026 in Gopalakrishnan v The Home Office, a personal injury claim arising from immigration detention in which the Home Office pleaded fundamental dishonesty.

High Court hears Home Office fundamental dishonesty issue in £7 million detention claimHigh Court hears Home Office fundamental dishonesty issue in £7 million detention claim

The High Court (Mansfield J) gave judgment on 6 November 2026 in Gopalakrishnan v The Home Office, a personal injury claim arising from immigration detention in which the Home Office pleaded fundamental dishonesty.

Key facts

The High Court (King's Bench Division, Mansfield J) handed down judgment in Gopalakrishnan v The Home Office [2026] EWHC 2856 (KB) on 6 November 2026, after hearings on 27 and 28 October and 6 November 2026. The claimant appeared in person; the Home Office was represented by counsel instructed by the Government Legal Department.

Background

The claimant came to the UK in 2010. He overstayed after a student visa expired in 2012 and made an unsuccessful asylum application in August 2013. He was held in immigration detention from September 2013 to February 2014, when he was released on health grounds.

His claim began in October 2013 as a judicial review of the asylum refusal and the decision to remove him to Sri Lanka. It was amended to add a claim for damages for personal injury. In 2023 he was granted indefinite leave to remain, the public law parts of the claim were compromised by a consent order, and the injury claim was transferred to the King's Bench Division.

His case was that treatment in detention caused serious, long-term psychiatric injury, leaving him unable to work and needing round-the-clock care. His preliminary Schedule of Loss, dated 9 January 2026, put the claim at £7,005,572.26, including £264,090 for pain, suffering and loss of amenity. That total did not include pension loss, deputyship costs or certain other heads of loss, and some heads were unparticularised. Since 2014 the proceedings had been conducted by a litigation friend, on the basis that he lacked capacity.

The new evidence

In 2026 the Home Office served video surveillance evidence, the litigation friend's own Home Office file, and a supplementary report from its psychiatric expert, Professor Maden. The Home Office submitted that this showed the claimant does not now suffer from a serious mental health condition and likely never did, and that he and the litigation friend are in a relationship and have three children, the eldest born in 2019.

What followed

The Home Office was allowed to amend its defence to plead fundamental dishonesty. The litigation friend's appointment was terminated on the basis that the claimant does not now lack capacity. His solicitors came off the record and he discontinued the claim. On 20 August 2026 Lambert J vacated the 10-day trial and, under CPR PD44 para 12.4(c), directed a trial of whether the claim was fundamentally dishonest.

That issue came before Mansfield J. The judgment records the pleaded case and the medical evidence relied on, including reports from Dr Dinshaw Master dated 19 August 2021, 11 July 2025 and 11 May 2026.

What this means for people with detention injury claims

This judgment concerns one claim and its own facts. It records that, in this case, the court directed a separate trial of the question of fundamental dishonesty after the Home Office served new evidence. Anyone involved in a similar claim should take legal advice on their own circumstances.

Sources

  • Vengadeswara Raw Gopalakrishnan v The Home Office [2026] EWHC 2856 (KB), High Court (King's Bench Division), 6 November 2026: https://caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ewhc/kb/2026/2856

Connaught Law News reports legal changes and judgments in plain English. It is news, not legal advice: the outcome in your own case depends on your facts, so speak to one of our solicitors before acting. We check every item against its source, but mistakes can happen; rely on the linked document, and tell us if you spot an error.