In a Home Office appeal over a care firm's revoked sponsor licence, Lord Justice Peter Jackson said compliance with annual salaries for uneven-hours workers needs a rounded assessment, not a rigid monthly test.
Key facts
- Who: Sponsors of skilled migrant workers and the workers they sponsor, where a Certificate of Sponsorship states an annual salary.
- From: Judgment date: 5 November 2026
- Source: Treal Care (UK) Limited, R (on the application of) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2026] EWCA Civ 1420
The Court of Appeal (Civil Division) handed down judgment on 5 November 2026 in R (Treal Care (UK) Limited) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2026] EWCA Civ 1420. Lord Justice Peter Jackson gave the lead judgment. He sat with Lord Justice Green and Lord Justice Fancourt. The hearing took place on 6 October 2026.
Background. Treal Care supplies care staff to the NHS, local authorities and clinical care groups. It was granted an A-rated sponsor licence in December 2021, allowing it to sponsor 75 migrant workers through Certificates of Sponsorship (CoS). By 2024 it had about 85 employees, around 75 of them working under a CoS.
The Home Office suspended the licence on 21 August 2024 after a compliance visit in March 2024. On 1 October 2024 it communicated its decision to revoke the licence on two grounds:
- that three employees had not been paid the salary stated in their CoS (the Salary Issue); and
- that there was no genuine vacancy for them (the Genuine Vacancy Issue).
Treal Care brought a judicial review claim. On 16 July 2025 Simon Tinkler, sitting as a Deputy High Court Judge, quashed the decision ([2025] EWHC 1797 (Admin)). The Home Secretary did not challenge the finding on genuine vacancy, so the appeal concerned only the Salary Issue. The Court of Appeal was told that Treal Care's licence has remained in place pending the appeal.
The question. The appeal centred on the Home Secretary's policy that a sponsor licence will be revoked if a sponsor pays a migrant worker less than the sponsor said it would. How is that to be read and applied?
The Home Secretary's case. Counsel accepted that the Guidance does not provide for assessment by month. He argued that it does not prevent it either, and that a month-by-month approach is the only workable one for workers paid monthly. Where a CoS gives an annual figure, he said, the sponsor has an obligation to pay at least one-twelfth of it each month, and must report any shortfall. Otherwise, he said, an annual total could mask periods of substantial underpayment. He also argued there was no residual discretion not to revoke once the mandatory conditions were met.
He did accept three points:
- there must be a fair relationship between the assessment period and the annual salary;
- an apparent shortfall can be explained; and
- a recent amendment to the Immigration Rules did not sit easily with his submission.
Treal Care's case. It argued that the benchmark is what appears on the CoS. A requirement to pay one-twelfth of the annual salary every month, it said, is inconsistent with the Guidance, the Immigration Rules and the scheme as a whole, and would produce absurd results.
The decision. Lord Justice Peter Jackson said he would dismiss the appeal. His central conclusion was that compliance with an annual salary commitment made to workers who work uneven hours requires a rounded assessment. It does not call for a rigid application of a requirement to pay at least one-twelfth of the annual figure every month.
The reasoning below. The judge at first instance found the conclusions about two of the three workers irrational, so the stated basis for the decision could not stand. He also held that if the Home Office meant to rely on the third worker alone, Treal Care should have been given a chance to respond. The Genuine Vacancy Issue depended entirely on the Salary Issue.
He also rejected an argument under section 31(2A) of the Senior Courts Act 1981. The Home Office said the decision should stand because it was highly likely the outcome for Treal Care would not have been substantially different. The judge found that Treal Care had not committed the acts that bring mandatory revocation into play.
What this means for sponsors and sponsored workers
The judgment concerns how pay is assessed where a CoS states an annual salary and hours are uneven. Lord Justice Peter Jackson's conclusion is that this calls for a rounded assessment rather than a rigid monthly test.
Each case turns on its own facts. Anyone facing a suspension or revocation of a sponsor licence may wish to take legal advice before any deadline passes.
Sources
- Treal Care (UK) Limited, R (on the application of) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2026] EWCA Civ 1420, Court of Appeal (Civil Division), 5 November 2026: https://caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ewca/civ/2026/1420
