Connaught Law News

Immigration Law · Judgment

Court of Appeal considers procedural fairness in sponsor licence revocation

The Court of Appeal gave judgment on 29 October 2026 on the reach of the common law duty of procedural fairness in the system for approving employers to sponsor migrant workers, affecting licensed sponsors.

Court of Appeal considers procedural fairness in sponsor licence revocationCourt of Appeal considers procedural fairness in sponsor licence revocation

The Court of Appeal gave judgment on 29 October 2026 on the reach of the common law duty of procedural fairness in the system for approving employers to sponsor migrant workers, affecting licensed sponsors.

Key facts

Lord Justice Arnold gave the judgment in the Court of Appeal (Civil Division), sitting with Lady Justice Asplin and Lady Justice Elisabeth Laing. The appeal was heard on 20 October 2026. The principal issue was the ambit of the common law duty of procedural fairness in the system for approving employers to sponsor migrant workers.

Background

TJ Trading Express Limited runs a petrol station with an attached convenience shop. It applied for a skilled worker sponsor licence on 21 July 2022, and the licence was granted on 27 September 2022.

On 15 November 2023 its director assigned a Certificate of Sponsorship (CoS) for the job of "Petrol Station Manager". The worker was the director's brother-in-law, and this had not been noted on the CoS. A review of Home Office records revealed the family link.

The Secretary of State revoked the licence by a decision dated 6 March 2024. The decision said the role appeared to have been created solely to facilitate the worker's entry to or stay in the UK. It relied on two grounds in Annex C1 of Part 3 of the sponsor guidance, each described as sufficient on its own, and stated that there was no right of appeal.

TJ Trading brought a judicial review. Hill J upheld the challenge and quashed the decision in a judgment dated 22 May 2025. The Secretary of State appealed with permission granted by Dove LJ.

The framework

The sponsorship system has no specific statutory basis. The courts have held that the Home Secretary has an implied power under the Immigration Act 1971 to run it, provided it is not inconsistent with the Act or the Immigration Rules. The system is set out in the guidance "Workers and Temporary Workers: guidance for sponsors". Version 03/23 of Part 3 was in force at the time of the decision.

That guidance describes sponsorship as "a privilege not a right". It requires sponsors to disclose, by adding a sponsor note, if they assign a CoS to a family member of anyone within the sponsor organisation where it is a small or medium-sized business. For a large business, the duty applies where the sponsor is aware it is assigning a CoS to a family member of anyone else within the organisation.

It is common ground that, even where a mandatory ground for revocation applies, the Secretary of State has a residual discretion not to revoke. In an earlier Court of Appeal case, Prestwick, the court held that she was not obliged to consider the impact of revocation on the sponsor's business, its employees and others.

The question

The judgment sets out the classic statement of procedural fairness in R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex parte Doody. Fairness depends on the context of the decision and is not applied identically in every situation. It will very often require that a person who may be adversely affected has an opportunity to make representations and is told the gist of the case they have to answer.

What this means for sponsor licence holders

The case concerns how far a sponsor is entitled to fair procedures when the Home Office acts against its licence. Sponsors facing compliance action should read the full judgment or take advice on it.

Sponsors should check that their records and sponsor notes meet the duties in the guidance, including the duty to disclose family links on a CoS. A revocation decision may state that there is no right of appeal. Anyone facing revocation or other action against a licence should get advice.

Sources

Connaught Law News reports legal changes and judgments in plain English. It is news, not legal advice: the outcome in your own case depends on your facts, so speak to one of our solicitors before acting. We check every item against its source, but mistakes can happen; rely on the linked document, and tell us if you spot an error.