Connaught Law News

Immigration Law · Judgment

Court of Appeal applies Akbars to illegal working civil penalty notices

On 11 November 2026 the Court of Appeal upheld one employer's £80,000 illegal working penalty notice as valid, while the Home Office withdrew another after the Supreme Court's Akbars ruling on penalty notices.

Court of Appeal applies Akbars to illegal working civil penalty noticesCourt of Appeal applies Akbars to illegal working civil penalty notices

On 11 November 2026 the Court of Appeal upheld one employer's £80,000 illegal working penalty notice as valid, while the Home Office withdrew another after the Supreme Court's Akbars ruling on penalty notices.

Key facts

In Jen & Jamie Limited v The Secretary of State for the Home Department [2026] EWCA Civ 1446, handed down on 11 November 2026, the Court of Appeal (Civil Division) heard two linked appeals. Lord Justice Dingemans gave the judgment. The appeals, heard on 13 and 14 October 2026, concerned the scope of the court's discretion under section 17(3) of the 2006 Act to take account of factors not set out in the 2024 Code of Practice when reducing civil penalties for employing people without the right to work.

Background

Jen & Jamie Limited, trading as Somerset Convenience Store, was issued a penalty notice on 9 August 2024 after Home Office officers visited the store in July 2024. The notice imposed £40,000 for each of two alleged illegal workers, £80,000 in total. The store denied that either woman was employed. The County Court in Middlesbrough found that both were employed and dismissed the appeal. The second appellant, Balbir Singh Johal, also appealed a penalty. His case came from the County Court at Cardiff.

The new ground

Shortly before the hearing, both appellants asked to add a ground based on the Supreme Court's decision in Akbars Restaurant v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2026] UKSC 26, delivered on 27 July 2026. That decision held that section 15(6)(a) of the 2006 Act requires the Home Office to specify, in the penalty notice and statement of case, which limb of section 15(1) it relies on.

The Home Office opposed the late application. The Court of Appeal allowed it, saying it is important to deal with the law as it is, not as it was misunderstood to be. The hearing was not adjourned, and the costs of the amendment were reserved.

The decision on validity

The Home Office conceded that Mr Johal's penalty notice was invalid and withdrew it. It said a new notice would be served, consistent with the approach contemplated in Akbars, and one has now been served.

For Somerset Store, the court looked at the notice as a whole, including the annexed statement of case. The notice gave the reason "breach of work restrictions". The statement explained that one woman had permission to work as a skilled worker for a named sponsor, with limited extra hours allowed only in eligible occupations. It said she was working as a shop assistant, which is not an eligible occupation. The court held that this identified section 15(1)(b)(iii), under which the worker is subject to conditions preventing the work. The notice was therefore valid.

The discretion issue

The court also considered how the County Court should approach its discretion under section 17(3) and whether the penalties were too high. It reviewed earlier case law, including Roth and Loane, in which courts looked at the fairness of penalty schemes and the matters a court may treat as relevant.

What this means for employers

  • A penalty notice and its statement of case must say why the Home Office thinks the employer is liable, including which limb of section 15(1) is relied on. Courts read the notice and statement together.
  • The Home Office accepted that Mr Johal's notice was invalid, and it withdrew that notice and served a new one.
  • Whether a notice meets these requirements depends on its wording, so employers and their advisers may wish to compare the notice and statement of case with the judgment.

Sources

Connaught Law News reports legal changes and judgments in plain English. It is news, not legal advice: the outcome in your own case depends on your facts, so speak to one of our solicitors before acting. We check every item against its source, but mistakes can happen; rely on the linked document, and tell us if you spot an error.