Connaught Law News

Immigration Law · Judgment

Court of Appeal considers kidnap for ransom under trafficking victim definition

The Court of Appeal has ruled on whether kidnapping a person and forcing him to contact his family to pay a ransom amounts to exploitation under the legal definition of a victim of human trafficking.

Court of Appeal considers kidnap for ransom under trafficking victim definitionCourt of Appeal considers kidnap for ransom under trafficking victim definition

The Court of Appeal has ruled on whether kidnapping a person and forcing him to contact his family to pay a ransom amounts to exploitation under the legal definition of a victim of human trafficking.

Key facts

Background

The Court of Appeal (Civil Division) handed down judgment in [2026] EWCA Civ 1411 on 4 November 2026. Lord Justice Lewis gave the judgment, sitting with Lord Justice Bean and Lord Justice Edis. The hearing took place on 15 October 2026.

The respondent, AAM, left Syria in 2021 and went to Libya. While he was travelling between Benghazi and Tripoli he was kidnapped and held captive for one month. He was forced to speak to his family by telephone and tell them to send money. A ransom was paid and he was released. He later travelled to the United Kingdom and claimed to be a victim of modern slavery.

The case was referred to the National Referral Mechanism, the means of identifying potential victims of slavery and trafficking and ensuring they have support. The Secretary of State decided he was not a victim of modern slavery because he was not a victim of exploitation. Her view was that being held captive and forced to contact his family to extort a ransom was not exploitation, as he was not required to work or perform any service for his captors.

AAM brought a claim for judicial review. In [2025] EWHC 447 (Admin), Mr Justice Macdonald held that the Secretary of State had taken too narrow an approach. He considered that whether kidnap for ransom amounts to exploitation depends on the facts of the case. He quashed the decision and sent it back for reconsideration.

The question

The Secretary of State appealed on two grounds: that the judge was wrong to conclude that kidnap for ransom is modern slavery or trafficking within the Regulations, and that the Secretary of State had failed adequately to consider AAM's claim.

The Court of Appeal identified the sole issue as whether kidnapping a person, and forcing him to contact his family in order to have them pay a ransom for his release, falls within the definition of being exploited in regulation 3(6)(d) of the Regulations.

That provision treats a person as exploited if subjected to force, threats or deception designed to induce them to provide services of any kind, to provide another person with benefits of any kind, or to enable another person to acquire benefits of any kind.

What this means for people whose trafficking claims are decided under the Regulations

The judgment concerns how one limb of the definition of exploitation in regulation 3(6)(d) is interpreted. The outcome of any individual claim depends on its own facts, so anyone with a decision to consider should check the full judgment and the reasons given in their own decision letter.

Sources

  • AAM v The Secretary of State for the Home Department [2026] EWCA Civ 1411, Court of Appeal (Civil Division), 4 November 2026: https://caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ewca/civ/2026/1411

Connaught Law News reports legal changes and judgments in plain English. It is news, not legal advice: the outcome in your own case depends on your facts, so speak to one of our solicitors before acting. We check every item against its source, but mistakes can happen; rely on the linked document, and tell us if you spot an error.