The Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber) held that one ground for modifying a restrictive covenant was made out but declined to exercise its discretion, so a covenant against dwellinghouse use at Shride Barn, Othery, stays in place.
Key facts
- Who: Landowners bound by restrictive covenants, and neighbours who have the benefit of them
- From: 5 November 2026 (judgment date)
- Source: Johnson Aboaba & Anor v Steven Phillip, [2026] UKUT 424 (LC)
Background
In [2026] UKUT 424 (LC), decided on 5 November 2026, the Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber) heard an application under section 84 of the Law of Property Act 1925 to discharge or modify a restrictive covenant. Mrs Diane Martin TD MRICS FAAV decided the case.
Mr Johnson Aboaba and Ms Lena Buhler own land next to their house at Shride Barn. On it is a former barn, redeveloped in 2008 as a home office, laboratory and workshop and now known as the annexe. Somerset Council granted a certificate of existing lawful use on 12 February 2024 for "ancillary residential accommodation".
The applicants bought the property on 3 July 2024. They have used the annexe intermittently for holiday lettings and for stays by friends and family. On 20 April 2026 the council granted retrospective planning permission for "change of use of outbuilding to annexe and holiday let".
The covenant comes from a transfer dated 9 May 2003. It prohibits erecting any dwellinghouse on the land and prohibits converting or using any building on it as a dwellinghouse. Its benefit lies with the neighbour, Mr Steven Phillip, who bought Shride Farm House on 9 June 2023 and objected to the application.
The question
Could the covenant be discharged or modified to permit holiday letting? The tribunal considered, among others, ground (a) (the covenant is obsolete) and ground (aa) (it impedes a reasonable use of the land without securing practical benefits of substantial value, and money would be adequate compensation).
The decision
Ground (a) was not made out. Ground (aa) was made out, but the tribunal did not exercise its discretion to order modification, so the covenant remains.
The reasoning
On obsolescence, the tribunal inferred that the covenant's purpose was to protect Shride Farm House from residential conversion or development closer to it. It declined to make findings about tourist activity at the objector's own property, saying that was within his control and did not prevent the covenant's purpose from being achieved. It did not treat a handful of other tourist businesses nearby as evidence of a change in the character of the neighbourhood, and found that both houses enjoy a peaceful rural location.
The tribunal accepted that the character of the application land had changed, but said this made the covenant even more important, not obsolete. There was no history of tolerated breach by holiday letting that would prevent enforcement by injunction.
On ground (aa), it was not disputed that holiday use could be considered reasonable given the planning permission, or that the covenant impeded it. The objector and his family had experienced guests in the annexe. They said they could hear noise from the terrace, particularly when the jacuzzi was in use. If alcohol was being consumed, the noise could be loud and involve swearing, and on one occasion it continued until 3.00 am.
On discretion, the objector argued that the applicants bought knowing of the covenant. He said that in March 2024 he was asked whether he would agree an amendment and refused. He also submitted that the applicants began holiday lettings without an amended covenant or planning permission, and applied for planning permission only after starting their application to the tribunal.
What this means for landowners and neighbours
- Even where a statutory ground is made out, the tribunal still has a discretion whether to modify a covenant, and in this case it did not do so.
- If you are buying land or changing how a building is used, check the title documents and the terms of any covenant first.
- If you are facing an application to modify a covenant, or an alleged breach, consider getting legal advice.
Sources
- Johnson Aboaba & Anor v Steven Phillip, [2026] UKUT 424 (LC), Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber), 5 November 2026: https://caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ukut/lc/2026/424
