Government guidance on the Tenant Fees Act 2019 explains when landlords in England can claim damages for breach of a tenancy agreement or recover cleaning costs, and why routine cleaning fees are likely prohibited.
Key facts
- Who: Landlords, letting agents, tenants and lodgers in England (the Tenant Fees Act 2019 applies in England only)
- From: Already in force
- Source: Fees you can charge as part of a tenancy
The guidance explains the Tenant Fees Act 2019, which defines what payments landlords and letting agents can ask of tenants and lodgers. It includes sections on damages for breach of contract and on requirements to pay for cleaning.
Damages for breach of contract
A landlord can require a payment of damages for breach of a tenancy agreement. The guidance says that in most cases it will be appropriate to recover damages through the tenancy deposit at the end of the tenancy.
Damages can be sought during the tenancy where that is appropriate. One example is the cost of repairing a broken window that cannot reasonably wait, where the tenant is responsible. This may be by agreement with the tenant or through legal proceedings.
Damages can only recover losses or costs the landlord has actually incurred because of the breach. A claim must be supported by evidence of the loss or cost, and the evidence should be given to the tenant. The exception is a default fee for late rent or a lost key or security device that the tenancy agreement requires.
Claims aimed at deterring a breach or punishing a tenant are generally not enforceable. The guidance gives examples of clauses likely to be unfair because they are fixed charges or penalties not linked to a genuine loss:
- a £25 fixed penalty for any letters, emails or phone calls used to chase rent arrears that are 7 days or more overdue
- a blanket £100 per hour for a contractor to visit the property for repairs or maintenance
- a fixed £50 charge for a missed appointment with a contractor
Cleaning
A landlord cannot routinely require a tenant to pay a cleaning fee. Any automatic requirement to pay for cleaning would likely be a prohibited payment.
A tenant is still responsible for returning the property in the condition they found it, allowing for fair wear and tear from reasonable use. If it is not returned in that condition, cleaning costs can be recovered by a claim against the tenancy deposit or for damages. Any claim should be supported by evidence of costs incurred.
Prohibited payments
A fee that is not allowed is a prohibited payment. The local council can issue a financial penalty of up to £5,000 for a first breach. A second or subsequent breach within 5 years of a previous penalty can lead to court action or a penalty of up to £30,000. A tenant can also apply to the First-tier Tribunal, which can order the fee to be returned.
A landlord can appeal a financial penalty, or an order to repay a prohibited payment, to the First-tier Tribunal. The deadline is 28 days from the day after the final notice for the penalty was given, or 7 to 14 days after the prohibited payment has to be paid.
What this means for landlords and tenants
Landlords may wish to check that tenancy agreements do not contain fixed charges or automatic cleaning fees, and that any claim is backed by evidence of actual cost.
Tenants who have been asked to pay a cleaning fee or a fixed charge can look at whether it reflects a genuine, evidenced loss.
Anyone unsure whether a charge is allowed, or facing a penalty with an appeal deadline running, should get advice promptly.
