The Court of Appeal has dismissed Allianz's appeal against a ruling that largely refused it summary judgment in a dispute over housing warranty cover for a 72-flat Portsmouth block, affecting the owner and insurer.
Key facts
- Who: Vivid Housing Limited, freehold owner of a 72-flat block in Portsmouth, and its insurer Allianz Global Corporate & Specialty SE.
- From: 3 November 2026 (judgment date)
- Source: Vivid Housing Limited v Allianz Global Corporate & Specialty SE [2026] EWCA Civ 1389
Vivid Housing Limited owns the freehold of a block of 72 flats at Collins Place, 189 Victoria Road North, Portsmouth. It is in effect the insured under a Housing Warranty Insurance Policy for the development. The policy was issued by Building LifePlans Ltd acting under a binding authority from the insurer, Allianz Global Corporate & Specialty SE.
Clause 3(a)(iii) of the policy covers the cost of repairing, replacing or strengthening the premises following a defect that becomes manifest and is notified during the Period of Insurance and causes "the threat of imminent destruction or physical damage to the Premises which requires immediate remedial measures for the prevention of destruction or physical damage within the Period of Insurance". The Period of Insurance ran from 22 May 2008 to 21 May 2020. Vivid notified a claim on or about 19 May 2020.
Vivid alleges fire safety defects, including combustible Rockpanel cladding on a building over 18 metres high, missing or defective vertical and horizontal cavity barriers, and building debris left in the cavities.
Allianz applied for summary judgment, arguing that Vivid's case had no real prospect of success on the remaining defects. It asked the court to proceed on the assumption that the alleged defects are defects within the meaning of the policy. On 16 December 2025 Mrs Justice Jefford dismissed the majority of that application ([2025] EWHC 3315 (TCC)). Allianz appealed.
The question
The appeal focused on the meaning of "the threat of imminent destruction or physical damage to the Premises" in clause 3(a)(iii), and in particular whether the judge gave the word "imminent" proper effect.
The decision
On 3 November 2026 the Court of Appeal (Lord Justice Stuart-Smith, with Lord Justice Phillips and Lord Justice Peter Jackson agreeing) dismissed the appeal.
The reasoning
The court said the parties appeared to be closer together the longer the hearing went on. It held that the judge had adopted the formulation of Christopher Clarke J in an earlier case, Gerling, under which whether damage is sufficiently likely to happen sufficiently soon is a question of fact and degree. The judge asked whether, in August 2019, the risk of fire was sufficiently serious and would eventuate sufficiently soon. Her conclusion that there was a prospect a reasonable observer would see a serious risk of fire and a threat of damage sufficiently soon was one she was entitled to reach.
On urgent remedial works, the court said there is an obvious relationship between the severity of the risk and the urgency of proposed repairs. The terms of Vivid's notification to Allianz were not determinative. The prioritisation of compartmentation defects in a report by CBRE was, in the court's view, much more informative. The court said it was at least a tenable submission that adopting a waking watch is a remedial step. It noted that it had not been directed to any evidence about other remedial works Vivid had taken or the reasons for their timeframe. It described these as matters for resolution at a trial, not on a summary judgment application.
Because the appeal failed, the court did not express a view on two alternative formulations of the test put forward by Vivid in its Respondent's Notice.
What this means for building owners and insurers
The Court of Appeal upheld the judge's refusal of summary judgment on the defects in issue in the appeal. It treated two questions as matters of fact and degree for trial rather than a summary judgment application: whether a defect creates a threat of imminent damage, and whether remedial works are urgent. Anyone with a similar claim or policy should check the wording of their cover and the dates of the Period of Insurance and of any notification.
Sources
- Vivid Housing Limited v Allianz Global Corporate & Specialty SE [2026] EWCA Civ 1389, Court of Appeal (Civil Division), 3 November 2026: https://caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ewca/civ/2026/1389
