The Family Court at Bournemouth gave a reserved fact-finding judgment on 9 November 2026 in a private children case, EM v PF, affecting parents in child arrangements and non-molestation proceedings.
Key facts
- Who: Parents involved in private law children proceedings that include a non-molestation application.
- From: 9 November 2026
- Source: EM v PF (Fact Finding) [2026] EWFC 327 (B)
Background
Recorder Reed KC gave judgment in the Family Court sitting in Bournemouth (case number BH26P00286) on 9 November 2026, after a three-day hearing on 28 to 30 October 2026. The judgment was delivered in private and published on condition that the anonymity of the child and members of his family is strictly preserved. Failure to comply is a contempt of court.
The parties are the mother (EM, applicant) and the father (PF, respondent), parents of a six-year-old boy, B. The court described him as dearly loved by both parents and strongly attached to each of them. Everyone agreed he is probably neurodivergent, and he has recently been issued with an EHCP.
The proceedings began in November 2025, when the mother applied without notice for a non-molestation order. In May 2026 the mother stopped contact after an alleged breach of the interim non-molestation order, and the father brought an application in respect of child arrangements. An order for supervised contact was made at the first hearing and remains in place. After a Child Impact Report in July, the case was set down for a fact-finding hearing.
The question
The hearing concerned a subset of the mother's allegations against the father. Earlier judges had considered these necessary and proportionate to determine, broadly allegations from early 2025 onwards. They decided not to determine some of the mother's older domestic abuse allegations, and not to determine the father's allegations, on the basis that those were better dealt with as welfare issues. Neither parent appealed those decisions.
The Family Law Act and Children Act proceedings have been consolidated. The parties accepted that the conclusions reached might or might not decide the non-molestation application. The interim order was due to expire on 11 November 2026.
The evidence
The court read two bundles of about 900 pages, including witness statements, WhatsApp messages, nursery and school records, local authority and CAMHS documents, police disclosure and the Child Impact Report.
After the evidence closed, the judge was asked to admit, and did admit, a 57-page set of WhatsApp messages that had been left out of the transcript originally exhibited. They covered the summer of 2025, leading up to the mother's first call to the police in September 2025 and her non-molestation application. The judge called them obviously highly relevant.
The judge found it surprising that the relevance of the messages was not immediately obvious, that the exhibited transcript did not say it was incomplete, and that the gap was not picked up or remedied by either side. The judge said they could not and did not try to pierce the veil of privilege, and made no criticism of the mother or the father for the approach taken.
The judgment also compares what the mother told the police and professionals with the school records. For example, a teacher's observation of the father's overbearing behaviour, which the mother reported on 7 September 2025, was not corroborated by contemporaneous school entries, and there was no record of staff raising concern about the father standing over the mother at a meeting.
What this means for parents in private children proceedings
- In this case, the court tested the parents' accounts against records such as messages, school entries and police logs.
- In this case, messages missing from an exhibited transcript were admitted after the evidence had closed, and the judge treated them as highly relevant.
- If you are involved in similar proceedings, get legal advice on your own situation and on any deadlines before they pass.
Sources
- EM v PF (Fact Finding) [2026] EWFC 327 (B), Family Court (Bournemouth), 9 November 2026: https://caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ewfc/b/2026/327
