The Court of Appeal has allowed a mother's appeal against refusal of leave to oppose an adoption order for her young child, D, holding that this was a clear case for leave under section 47(5).
Key facts
- Who: Parents facing an adoption application for a child who is subject to a placement order, and the local authorities and prospective adopters involved.
- From: 11 November 2026 (judgment date)
- Source: G (A Child: Leave to Oppose Adoption) [2026] EWCA Civ 1445
In G (A Child: Leave to Oppose Adoption) [2026] EWCA Civ 1445, the Court of Appeal (Civil Division) gave judgment on 11 November 2026, after a hearing on 3 November 2026. Lord Justice Peter Jackson gave the judgment, sitting with Lord Justice Newey and Lady Justice May. The appeal was from the Family Court at Brighton.
Background
Care proceedings concerning D began in April 2024 and she was placed in foster care. The concerns centred on the mother's drug and alcohol use, her mental health history and her relationships with violent and abusive partners. The basic care of D and the quality of contact were described as good.
After a three-day hearing in March 2025, HHJ Levey made a care order and a placement order. He accepted that the mother was committed to rehabilitation and that there was a strong bond between mother and child. He concluded, however, that the concerns had not been sufficiently addressed and could not be resolved within D's timescales.
D was placed with a prospective adopter in October 2025, and an adoption application was issued in January 2026.
The question
The mother applied for leave to oppose the adoption order. The question on appeal was whether the judge was right to refuse it.
The decision
The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal. Lord Justice Peter Jackson said this was a clear case for leave. He added that if leave was not granted to this parent, it was difficult to see how section 47(5) offered the meaningful remedy that Parliament intended.
The reasoning
At the first stage, the judge had assessed the changes in the mother's circumstances as genuine and substantial.
The judgment set out the question for the second stage, taken from Re M [2023] EWCA Civ 404: taking account of all the circumstances and giving paramount consideration to the child's lifelong welfare, should the court revisit the plan for adoption that it approved when making the placement order? Prospects of success are an important element, but not a test in itself.
The court also cited earlier guidance that:
- judges should take a long view of the child's welfare throughout life
- they should not give undue weight to the impact on prospective adopters of a contested application
- the test should not be set so high that it cannot be achieved
- the decision on leave should not develop into a trial of the adoption application on incomplete evidence
The mother's counsel argued that the judge had treated gaps in the evidence as a reason to refuse leave. The local authority supported the judge's decision, and asked in the alternative for guidance on how first instance judges should assess the second stage where a parent has shown substantial change. Lord Justice Peter Jackson said there is ample guidance on the statutory provision, which can be applied equally to stronger and weaker applications.
What this means for parents facing adoption applications
The Court of Appeal found that, on the facts of this case, leave to oppose should have been granted. The court's approach to the second stage is the question set out above, centred on the child's lifelong welfare.
Sources
- G (A Child: Leave to Oppose Adoption) [2026] EWCA Civ 1445, Court of Appeal (Civil Division), 11 November 2026: https://caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ewca/civ/2026/1445
